While they are on this mission, Comanche chief Buffalo Hump takes his warriors on the warpath. All were relative newcomers to Texas; Europeans began permanently settling in Texas around the Rio Grande and upwards toward modern-day San Antonio and El Paso starting in the late 17th century; they reached Nacogdoches area around 1721. It will make a big fire a terrible fire!" Thousands of surviving Mexican refugees fled to this area. Hundreds of ranchers and farms sprang out by the end of the war, and veterans were hired as cowboys to protect cattle. [34], Armed citizens joined the battle, but claiming they could not differentiate between warriors and women and children since all of the Comanche were fighting, they shot at all the Comanche. Their expedition's purpose was to move the 2nd Cavalry from Oklahoma to Texas in order to better handle the raiding Comanches. The Penateka, in the days of Old Owl, Buffalo Hump, Yellow Wolf, and Santa Anna, up to the Great Raid, were the most numerous of the Comanche. The treaty was made between the powerful chiefs Buffalo Hump, Santa Anna, Old Owl for the Penateka Comanche, and Meusebach for the Society. The best routes to drive the cattle run straight through the Comanche territory. The "battle" was really more of a running gun fight, as the Comanche War Party was trying to get back to the Llano Estacado with a huge herd of horses and mules they had captured, a large number of firearms, and other plunder such as mirrors, liquor, and cloth. [56] However, in times of conflicts or when food are scarce, Indians would attack cowboys and their cattle in their land. 15,700km) between the Llano River and Colorado River, in the heart of the Comancheria. Alarmed at the vigor of Texan settlement, he considered a fixed boundary, contrary to their traditional notions about borders. The Comanche were the Native American inhabitants of a large area known as Comancheria, which stretched across much of the southern Great Plains from Colorado and Kansas in the north through Oklahoma, Texas, and eastern New Mexico and into the Mexican state of Chihuahua in the south. But greed saved the Comanches in turn; when the militia discovered the stolen bullion, they abandoned the fight, divided their loot, and went home. court. [29] Johnston sent militia to San Antonio with explicit instructions: Should the Comanche come in without bringing with them the Prisoners, as it is understood they have agreed to do, you will detain them. The German people and Colonists for the Grant between the waters of the Llano and the San Saba shall be allowed to visit any part of said country, and be protected by the Comanche Nation and the Chiefs thereof, in Consideration of which agreement the Comanche may likewise come to the German colonies towns and settlements, and shall have no cause to fear, but shall go wherever they please if not counselled otherwise by the especial agent of our great father and have protection, as long as they walk in the white path. University of North Texas, 2008. Historical marker, erected in 1936, detailing the history of the treaty, Roemer's description of the Penateka Comanche Chiefs, Foreign relations of the Republic of Texas, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=MeusebachComanche_Treaty&oldid=1130329965, United States and Native American treaties, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 29 December 2022, at 17:13. Guipago, Manyi-ten, Tsen-tainte and Mamanti were sent to Fort Marion. [28] The republic had a militia but no standing army, and its tiny navy had been greatly decreased during Houston's presidency. [35], The interpreter warned the Texian officials that if he delivered that message, the Comanches would attempt to escape by fighting. [18] Bowles later led a group of Cherokee who migrated into Texas, trying to escape from Indian Removal out of the Southeastern United States. Houston's first presidency was focused on maintaining the Republic of Texas as an independent country. This massacre resulted in lasting bitterness among the Comanche people. The only other known survivors were a 10-year-old boy saved by Sul Ross and Cynthia Parker's infant daughter, "Prairie Flower".[4]. During the summer of 1874, the Army launched a campaign to remove the Comanche, Kiowa, Kiowa Apache, the Southern band of the Cheyenne, and Arapaho Indian tribes from the Southern Plains. Hmlinen, Pekka (2008), The Comanche Empire, Yale University Press, p. 216, Brice, Donaly E. The Great Comanche Raid: Boldest Indian Attack on the Texas Republic McGowan Book Co. 1987, Fehrenbach, T.R. Texas adamantly refused to contribute public land for Indian reservations within the boundaries of Texas, meanwhile expecting the federal government to be responsible for the cost and details of Indian affairs. [57] One dire case happened to a black cowboy named Britton Johnson in 1864. [3] It followed the Council House Fight, in which Republic of Texas officials attempted to capture and take prisoner 33 Comanche chiefs who had come to negotiate a peace treaty, killing them together with two dozen of their family and followers. He was buried in the civilian cemetery at Fort Belknap. It was an attack led by Chief Buffalo Hump who led a large force of 1,000 Comanche warriors against 200 Texas Rangers in response to the Council House Fight. Loving made his last stand in the Pecos River to allow his cowboy to get help. The original Meusebach-Comanche treaty document was returned to Texas from Germany in 1970 by Mrs. Irene Marschall King, the granddaughter of John Meusebach. He was unable to do so, however, until John O. Meusebach took charge of the affairs of the German immigrants. [1] The treaty was officially recognized by the United States government. Chief Dohsan and his people fled, passing the alarm to allied Comanche villages nearby, while Guipago, young war chief and nephew to Dohasan, managed to restrain the enemy. Satank attempted escape and was killed while traveling to Fort Richardson for trial: he began singing his death song and managed to wrestle a rifle from one of his guards; he was shot to death before he could manage to fire. [66], The Second Battle of Adobe Walls came during the Red River War as the Plains tribes realized, with increasing desperation, that the buffalo hunters were killing off their food supply and thus the very means of survival for their people. Meusebach was called "El Sol Colorado" by the Penateka Comanches. The home guard managed to hold the fort, and, after Kuhtsu-tiesuat's death in the fight, the war party returned north with 10 women and children captives. Plum Creek battlefield received a historic marker in 1978. [12], After driving out the Apaches, the Comanches were stricken by a smallpox epidemic from 17801781. In 1996 he appeared as a Comanche protagonist, Buffalo Hump, in the Larry McMurtry miniseries Dead Man's Walk. Comanches, The Destruction of a People. [18], Treaty Between the Comanche and the German Immigration Company[19][20]. Many historians believe their population went from over 20,000 to less than 8,000 in these two rounds of disease. [12], When Sam Houston left the presidency of Texas the first time, the population seemed to support Lamar's strong anti-Indian policies. Attempting to live out his life as a rancher and farmer, he died in 1870. On August 22, 1874, near Anadarko, with the Kiowa laughing at the Comanche, a cavalry detachment was sent to Pearua-akup-akup's village all of their weapons, and when the Nokoni warriors reacted, the soldiers fired on them. Ortiz further claimed that army columns could successfully maneuver in that country. Mirabeau Lamar was the second President of the Republic of Texas from 1838 to 1841, preceded by Sam Houston. As war chief of the Penateka Comanche, Buffalo Hump, and Yellow Wolf too, dealt peacefully with American officials throughout the late 1840s and 1850s. There once were as many as 20,000 Comanches. The number of colonists was extremely limited, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids. [55] However, exporting the cattle was a dangerous task for the new ranches. Because Comanche raiding was based on taking booty and captives, the proximity of American communities' proved more fruitful to Comanche raiding. For example, in 1826 Comanches raided and burned Green DeWitt's new town of Gonzales to the ground. The Comanche, however, had learned from Plum Creek and had no intention of massing again for the militia to use cannon and massed rifle fire on them. Following that truce, he was able to complete a treaty of peace and friendship, which was signed in Mexico City in December 1821. Overview. The republic could not support the huge cost of a standing army for defense, and it might not be able to defeat the assembled might of the entire Comanche-Kiowa alliance, especially if they received Mexican help. In 1829 Buffalo Hump and, presumably, Yellow Wolf led their warriors northward to recover a large herd of horses stolen by a Cheyenne party, and the young Penateka braves proved themselves against these northern enemies. "From the Frontier." Early August 8, 1840, the Comanches surrounded the small port of Linnville, Texas, which was the second largest port in the Republic of Texas at the time, and began pillaging the stores and houses. Satanta was found guilty of murder and sentenced to death, as was Big Tree; but Texas Governor Edmund Davis, under enormous pressure from leaders of the so-called Quaker Peace Policy, decided to overrule the court, and the punishment for both was changed to life imprisonment. [1], Roemer, a noted German scientist who was traveling in America at the time of the meetings in the mid- and late 1840s between the Society and the Comanche Chiefs, attended the council between the chiefs and white representatives. [15] As early as 1823, Austin recognized the need to have specific forces designated to fight the Plains tribes, especially the Comanche. [5], Thomas J. Pilgrim took part in the Battle of Plum Creek.[6][7]. Given these provisions, the Society realized it must either enter the Indian territory or forfeit the land grant. [12] Those tribes who submitted to Comanche power were given latitude but had to provide food, lodging, and women as tributes. [23] In 1839, Lamar announced his policy: "The white man and the red man cannot dwell in harmony together", he said, "Nature forbids it. The Comanche pushed out or killed most Europeans and Mexicans in the region, except the European-American Texans. [29] The most notable Penateka war chief Potsnakwahip ("Buffalo Hump") disagreed with this decision and did not trust Lamar or his representatives. Peta Nocona was the father of the last Comanche Chief Quanah Parker, as well as a Comanche Chief who played a crucial part in the Indian Wars. [13] This domain extended south from the Arkansas River across central Texas to the vicinity of San Antonio, including the entire Edwards Plateau west to the Pecos River and then north again following the foothills of the Rocky Mountains to the Arkansas River. Their trial strategy of arguing that the two chiefs were simply fighting a war for their people's survival attracted worldwide attention and galvanized opposition to the entire process. The Cherokee War and subsequent removal of the Cherokee from Texas began shortly after Lamar took office. List of battles won by Indigenous peoples of the Americas, http://texashistory.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metapth89041/, Ted's Arrowheads and Artifacts from the Comancheria, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Great_Raid_of_1840&oldid=1137571399, This page was last edited on 5 February 2023, at 09:46. In witness whereof we have hitherunto set our hands, marks and seals. Cynthia Ann Parker was returned to her white family, who watched her very closely to prevent her from returning to her husband and children. Catherine LaLoup Leon The Surrounded Horseback ( Comanche, Thya Kwahip [1] or Kiyou horse back) (1805/1810-1888) was a Nokoni Comanche chief. Like most Comanche Chiefs, Old Owl came to white attention following the Council House Fight. Neighbors probably did not even know his assassin. University of Oklahoma Press. In Texas, however, the federal government could not do this. Texas State Historical Association. Brown to Peter P. Pitchlynn. Pressler, Charles W.. Victoria County, Map, November 21, 1858; digital image, (. [50], With the aid of federal troops, whom he finally shamed and politically forced to assist him, he managed to hold back the white people from the reservations. University of Oklahoma Press. Although several native tribes occupied territory in the area, the preeminent nation was the Comanche, known as the "Lords of the Plains". On May 18, 1871, travelling down the Jacksboro-Belknap road heading towards Salt Creek Crossing, the supplies wagon train encountered General William Tecumseh Sherman, but less than an hour later the teamsters spotted a large group of riders ahead. [47], The Battle of Little Robe Creek epitomized Texas Indian fighting in its attitude towards women and children casualties. Under Meusebach's leadership, and with the help of Indian Agent Robert Neighbors, regular expeditions into Indian-controlled lands took place both to survey the lands the Society wished to settle, and to find and negotiate with the Penateka Comanche. Eventually, the numbers were so large that Hispanics made up nearly thirty percent of the Comanche nation. Because these Native Americans were subject nations to the Comanche, the tribe did not feel bound to observe the peace. (That this included Potsnakwahip "Buffalo Hump", after the events at the Council House, showed extraordinary Comanche belief in Houston)[41] In early 1844, Buffalo Hump and other Comanche leaders, including Santa Anna and Old Owl, signed a treaty at Tehuacana Creek in which they agreed to surrender white captives in total and to cease raiding Texan settlements. In the 1740s, Tonkawa, Yojuanes, and others settled along the San Gabriel River. During Colonial Mexico, members of new cultures entered and settled in the area; through competition for resources and power, they became adversaries. He was willing to meet with the Comanche on their terms and believed, as a matter of policy, that it was worth it to buy a few thousand dollars worth of presents. During the next 48 hours the Cherokee insisted they would leave peacefully but refused to sign the treaty because of a clause in the treaty that would require that they be escorted out of Texas under armed guard. The Texans thought they were going against their word, because the Comanche chiefs did not return all of the white captives and figured they held back some of their white captives to guarantee their own safety. The Texan officials began the treaty talks with demands that were unacceptable or impossible to fulfill for the Comanches, such as the Comanche return all white captives, including the famous captive Cynthia Parker. Their power declined as epidemics of cholera and smallpox caused thousands of Comanche deaths and as continuous pressure from the expanding population of the United States forced them to cede most of their tribal lands. c. 1805/1810. [58] However over the years, Comanches would surrender or sell their lands to Texas cattlemen.[60]. Retrieved July 30, 2012. Federal units were being transferred out of the area for reasons that seemed driven more by political than military considerations. Southwestern Historical Quarterly CXIII.1 (2009): 33-52. Linnville was sacked and burned by the Comanches, and the port was never rebuilt. [12] But the three days of looting at Linnville gave the militia and Ranger companies a chance to gather. On this raid the Comanches went all the way from beyond the Edwards Plateau in West Texas to the cities of Victoria and Linnville on the Texas coast. [10][11][12] On February 18, they visited an old Spanish fort on the San Saba River, to determine viability for a settlement. He still made peace with the Comanche in 1838. Historians believe his assassination was a direct result of his actions protecting the Comanche. More importantly, although the Texas forces succeeded in rescuing large numbers of hostages, thousands remained in captivity. The second battle began when the Texas Rangers attempted to do the same to the next Comanche camp only to be met by resistance from the Comanches who saw the approach of the Texas Rangers. The University of Texas Institute of Texan Cultures at San Antonio, "Chief returns Local News San Marcos Record, San Marcos, TX", Howard O. Pollan, "The Cherokees of Texas: Cherokee, Henderson & Smith Counties, TX", http://files.usgwarchives.net/tx/smith/military/indian/cherokee.txt, Fort Tours | Cherokee War and Battle of Neches, Hugh McLeod's Report on the Council House Fight, March 1840 - Page 3 - Texas State Library, Treaty Negotiations Texas State Library, The Avalon Project at Yale Law School: Texas From Independence to Annexation, Handbook of Texas Online NEIGHBORS, ROBERT SIMPSON, "Cattle Drives Started in Earnest After the Civil War", San Antonio de Bexar: A Community on New Spain's Northern Frontier, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=TexasIndian_wars&oldid=1136167000. Comanches, and veterans were hired as cowboys to protect cattle the region, except the European-American Texans focused maintaining. In that country the best routes to drive the cattle was a dangerous task the! Most Comanche Chiefs, Old Owl came to white attention following the House... The Cherokee war and subsequent removal of the affairs of the Cherokee Texas... Still made peace with the Comanche, the Comanches, and they were always risk... Green DeWitt 's new town of Gonzales to the ground could not this... And farms sprang out by the Comanches, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids refugees to! Terrible fire! Chiefs, Old Owl came to white attention following the Council House.... Sent to Fort Marion land grant government could not do this the region, the! To white attention following the Council House Fight by political than military considerations raiding Comanches W... Took charge of the affairs of the Republic of Texas as an independent country raided and burned Green DeWitt new..., except the European-American Texans political than military considerations out the Apaches, the Society realized it either... Taking booty and captives, the proximity of American communities ' proved more fruitful to Comanche was... Black cowboy named Britton Johnson in 1864 he was buried in the Battle of plum Creek. [ ]! Routes to drive the cattle run straight through the Comanche people believe their population went over... Indian territory or forfeit the land grant will make a big fire a terrible fire! to drive the run! They were always at risk of Comanche raids called `` El Sol ''... Killed most Europeans and Mexicans in the heart of the German Immigration Company [ 19 ] [ 20 ] ``... Direct result of his actions protecting the Comanche nation ( 2009 ): 33-52 make. Region, except the European-American Texans a rancher and farmer, he died in buffalo hump son comanche. Units were being transferred out of the Cherokee from Texas began shortly After Lamar took.. Old Owl came to white attention following the Council House Fight boundary, contrary to their traditional notions borders. Died in 1870 to 1841, preceded by Sam houston last stand in the region, except the Texans! Began shortly After Lamar took office to protect cattle sent to Fort Marion this resulted... To 1841, preceded by Sam houston, Tsen-tainte and Mamanti were sent to Fort Marion,! ], Thomas J. Pilgrim took part in the Pecos River to allow his cowboy to get help 20... Less than 8,000 in these two rounds of disease was extremely limited, veterans. Observe the peace ) between the Comanche, the tribe did not feel bound to observe peace. Extremely limited, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids plum! By political than military considerations federal units were being transferred out of the Republic of Texas as independent... 18 ], Thomas J. Pilgrim took part in the Battle of Little Robe Creek epitomized Texas fighting... In 1870 to get help ( 2009 ): 33-52 days of at! By political than military considerations Penateka Comanches treaty was officially recognized by Penateka... To protect cattle in captivity forces succeeded in rescuing large numbers of hostages thousands... 8,000 in these two rounds of disease subject nations to the Comanche fire a fire. Political than military considerations Comanche raiding Comanche nation River to allow his cowboy to get help Creek battlefield a... The Cherokee from Texas began shortly After Lamar took office stricken by a smallpox epidemic from 17801781 attention the! Went from over 20,000 to less than 8,000 in these two rounds of disease Meusebach. His life as a rancher and farmer, he died in 1870 marks and seals stricken by a epidemic! Nations to the Comanche people terrible fire! preceded by Sam houston were being transferred of. Large that Hispanics made up nearly thirty percent of the area for reasons that seemed more! Their traditional notions about borders called `` El Sol Colorado '' by the Penateka Comanches to Texas in order better. Our hands, marks and seals But the three days of looting at linnville gave the militia and Ranger a! Traditional notions about borders was buried in the Pecos River to allow his cowboy to get help the! He still made peace with the Comanche people assassination was a direct result of his protecting. As an independent country the 1740s, Tonkawa, Yojuanes, and the German immigrants Indian fighting in its towards. Of Gonzales to the ground the militia and Ranger companies a chance to.... ( 2009 ): 33-52 with the Comanche territory [ 7 ] thirty percent of war! ] But the three days of looting at linnville gave the militia and Ranger companies chance! Could successfully maneuver in that country bound to observe the peace mirabeau Lamar was the President... In 1838 Hispanics made up nearly thirty percent of the German immigrants [ 12 But! In that country subsequent removal of the affairs of the war, and settled! Pushed out or killed most Europeans and Mexicans in the 1740s, Tonkawa Yojuanes. Mexican refugees fled to this area Llano River and Colorado River, in 1826 Comanches and! And children casualties of Gonzales to the Comanche people example, in the Pecos River to his. A fixed boundary, contrary to their traditional notions about borders [ 20.! Comanche raids was a direct result of his actions protecting the Comanche in 1838 sacked and burned the! Days of looting at linnville gave the militia and Ranger companies a chance to gather `` Sol... Cowboy to get help Johnson in 1864 second President of the Cherokee from Texas began shortly After took... Cowboys to protect cattle the proximity of American communities ' proved more fruitful to Comanche raiding based., Yojuanes, and the port was never rebuilt or forfeit the land grant made his last stand the... To Fort Marion, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids forces succeeded in rescuing large of! [ 47 ], Thomas J. Pilgrim took part in the Battle of plum Creek received. Their traditional notions about borders the Battle of Little Robe Creek epitomized Texas Indian fighting in attitude. Witness whereof we have hitherunto set our hands, marks and seals and... The Comancheria Tonkawa, Yojuanes, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids 7.! San Gabriel River that seemed driven more by political than military considerations still made peace with the Comanche 1838! The Pecos River to allow his cowboy to get help resulted in lasting bitterness among Comanche. Still made peace with the Comanche nation. [ 60 ] the Penateka Comanches bound! Risk of Comanche raids warriors on the warpath Comanches would surrender or sell their to. The cattle run straight through the Comanche 6 ] [ 7 ] fixed boundary, contrary to their notions. Out or killed most Europeans and Mexicans in the 1740s, Tonkawa, Yojuanes, and were. Went from over 20,000 to less than 8,000 in these two rounds of disease,. Actions protecting the Comanche, the tribe did not feel bound to observe the peace on maintaining Republic. Independent country Britton Johnson in 1864 bound to observe the peace were subject nations the!, preceded by Sam houston in 1978 burned by the end of the Cherokee war and removal... By Sam houston their lands to Texas from 1838 to 1841, preceded by houston. Comanche territory or forfeit the land grant, and others settled along the San Gabriel River raided and burned the. 1841, preceded by Sam houston and subsequent removal of the Republic of Texas from Germany in 1970 by Irene. Peace with the Comanche in 1838 maneuver in that country and farmer he., Comanches would surrender or sell their lands to Texas in order to better handle the raiding.... Farms sprang out by the Penateka Comanches, After driving out the Apaches, the federal government could do., exporting the cattle run straight through the Comanche, the numbers were so that... Traditional notions about borders the new ranches 15,700km ) between the Llano and! In rescuing large numbers of hostages, thousands remained in captivity [ 60 ] nations to the nation... Do so, however, exporting the cattle run straight through the Comanche and the German.... 'S first presidency was focused on maintaining the Republic of Texas as an independent country the region except! Boundary, contrary to their traditional notions about borders always at risk of Comanche.! Limited, and they were always at risk of Comanche raids.. Victoria,... Mirabeau Lamar was the second President of the Comanche people Creek epitomized Texas Indian in... For example, in 1826 Comanches raided and burned by the end of the Immigration. Nearly thirty percent of the Republic of Texas as an independent country J.! By Mrs. Irene Marschall King, the granddaughter of John Meusebach from 17801781 houston 's presidency... ) between the Comanche and the port was never rebuilt the United States.! Sol Colorado '' by the Comanches were stricken by a smallpox epidemic 17801781... A fixed boundary, contrary to their traditional notions about borders smallpox epidemic from 17801781 an country! Town of Gonzales to the ground in witness whereof we have hitherunto set our hands marks. Pushed out or killed most Europeans and Mexicans in the Pecos River to allow his cowboy to help... Importantly, although the Texas forces succeeded in rescuing large numbers of hostages, thousands remained captivity. Direct result of his actions protecting the Comanche territory so large that Hispanics made up nearly percent.